BIND Zone XFER Problems

[Kevin Darcy]

I cut and paste'd your non-working zone file and loaded it just fine. I had to
join the SOA and TXT records, of course, since they were split into separate
lines in my newsreader. And there was the usual "no default TTL set" warning,
since there was no $TTL directive. Strange, you said no errors or warnings, but
you should have at *least* gotten the TTL warning. Or, did you just edit the
$TTL directive before posting the zone file? Maybe you have something screwy
with your logging that is hiding the real error.

That "DNS Boss" TXT record is only 1 line, right?


- Kevin

Peter Ziemann wrote:

> Yes, but I have modified my zone file until I got it working
> (took me several hours trial-and-error). I have also tried
> before several BIND options - no change. Furtheron I
> have recompiled the whole BIND 8.2.2-P5 distribution
> and observed no errors & warning - again no change.
>
> I still do not know what the problem is. I think I will write a
> BUG REPORT for BIND 8.2.2-P5 & will help to trace down
> the problem with my environment/configuration.
>
> Peter Ziemann
>
> WORKING ZONE FILE:
> ==================
> pziemann.de.      IN     SOA    ns-unix.pziemann.de. hostmaster.pziemann.de.
> ( 2000021010 10800 3600 604800 86400 )
> pziemann.de.            IN     NS     ns-unix.pziemann.de.
> pziemann.de.            IN     NS     pns.dtag.de.
> pziemann.de.            IN     NS     techfac.techfak.uni-bielefeld.de.
> pziemann.de.     IN     A      62.154.221.2
> pziemann.de.     IN     MX     30     mail.pziemann.de.
> pziemann.de.     IN     MX     40     zeus.nic.dtag.de.
> router.pziemann.de.     IN     A      62.154.221.1
> ns-unix.pziemann.de.     IN     A      62.154.221.2
> www.pziemann.de.     IN     CNAME     ns-unix.pziemann.de.
> ftp.pziemann.de.     IN     CNAME     ns-unix.pziemann.de.
> telnet.pziemann.de.     IN     CNAME     ns-unix.pziemann.de.
> mail.pziemann.de.     IN     A      62.154.221.3
> tb.pziemann.de.     IN     CNAME     mail.pziemann.de.
> ws-fix3.pziemann.de.     IN     A      62.154.221.4
> ws-fix4.pziemann.de.     IN     A      62.154.221.5
> ws-dhcp1.pziemann.de.     IN     A      62.154.221.6
> ws-dhcp2.pziemann.de.     IN     A      62.154.221.7
> ws-dhcp3.pziemann.de.     IN     A      62.154.221.8
> ws-dhcp4.pziemann.de.     IN     A      62.154.221.9
> ws-dhcp5.pziemann.de.     IN     A      62.154.221.10
> ws-dhcp6.pziemann.de.     IN     A      62.154.221.11
> ppp-dialin1.pziemann.de.     IN     A      62.154.221.12
> ppp-dialin2.pziemann.de.     IN     A      62.154.221.13
> mgmt.pziemann.de.     IN     A      62.154.221.14
>
> NOT WORKING (original) ZONE FILE
> ============================
> pziemann.de.      IN     SOA    ns-unix.pziemann.de. hostmaster.pziemann.de.
> ( 00021010 10800 3600 604800 86400 )
> madebydnsboss     IN     TXT     "This map made by DNS Boss Software version
> DNS Boss 1.7 on:  00021010."
> pziemann.de.            IN     NS     ns-unix.pziemann.de.
> pziemann.de.            IN     NS     pns.dtag.de.
> pziemann.de.            IN     NS     techfac.techfak.uni-bielefeld.de.
> pziemann.de.     IN     A      62.154.221.2
> pziemann.de.     IN     MX     30     mail.pziemann.de.
> pziemann.de.     IN     MX     40     zeus.nic.dtag.de.
> localhost        IN     A      127.0.0.1
> router.pziemann.de.     IN     A      62.154.221.1
> router.pziemann.de.     IN     MX     30     mail.pziemann.de.
> router.pziemann.de.     IN     MX     40     zeus.nic.dtag.de.
> A1.pziemann.de.     IN     CNAME     router.pziemann.de.
> ns-unix.pziemann.de.     IN     A      62.154.221.2
> ns-unix.pziemann.de.     IN     MX     30     mail.pziemann.de.
> ns-unix.pziemann.de.     IN     MX     40     zeus.nic.dtag.de.
> ws0.pziemann.de.     IN     CNAME     ns-unix.pziemann.de.
> www.pziemann.de.     IN     CNAME     ns-unix.pziemann.de.
> ftp.pziemann.de.     IN     CNAME     ns-unix.pziemann.de.
> telnet.pziemann.de.     IN     CNAME     ns-unix.pziemann.de.
> A2.pziemann.de.     IN     CNAME     ns-unix.pziemann.de.
> mail.pziemann.de.     IN     A      62.154.221.3
> mail.pziemann.de.     IN     MX     30     mail.pziemann.de.
> mail.pziemann.de.     IN     MX     40     zeus.nic.dtag.de.
> ws1.pziemann.de.     IN     CNAME     mail.pziemann.de.
> mac1.pziemann.de.     IN     CNAME     mail.pziemann.de.
> tb.pziemann.de.     IN     CNAME     mail.pziemann.de.
> www1.pziemann.de.     IN     CNAME     mail.pziemann.de.
> ftp1.pziemann.de.     IN     CNAME     mail.pziemann.de.
> A3.pziemann.de.     IN     CNAME     mail.pziemann.de.
> ws-fix3.pziemann.de.     IN     A      62.154.221.4
> ws-fix3.pziemann.de.     IN     MX     30     mail.pziemann.de.
> ws-fix3.pziemann.de.     IN     MX     40     zeus.nic.dtag.de.
> ws2.pziemann.de.     IN     CNAME     ws-fix3.pziemann.de.
> A4.pziemann.de.     IN     CNAME     ws-fix3.pziemann.de.
> ws-fix4.pziemann.de.     IN     A      62.154.221.5
> ws-fix4.pziemann.de.     IN     MX     30     mail.pziemann.de.
> ws-fix4.pziemann.de.     IN     MX     40     zeus.nic.dtag.de.
> ws3.pziemann.de.     IN     CNAME     ws-fix4.pziemann.de.
> A5.pziemann.de.     IN     CNAME     ws-fix4.pziemann.de.
> ws-dhcp1.pziemann.de.     IN     A      62.154.221.6
> ws-dhcp1.pziemann.de.     IN     MX     30     mail.pziemann.de.
> ws-dhcp1.pziemann.de.     IN     MX     40     zeus.nic.dtag.de.
> ws4.pziemann.de.     IN     CNAME     ws-dhcp1.pziemann.de.
> A6.pziemann.de.     IN     CNAME     ws-dhcp1.pziemann.de.
> ws-dhcp2.pziemann.de.     IN     A      62.154.221.7
> ws-dhcp2.pziemann.de.     IN     MX     30     mail.pziemann.de.
> ws-dhcp2.pziemann.de.     IN     MX     40     zeus.nic.dtag.de.
> ws5.pziemann.de.     IN     CNAME     ws-dhcp2.pziemann.de.
> A7.pziemann.de.     IN     CNAME     ws-dhcp2.pziemann.de.
> ws-dhcp3.pziemann.de.     IN     A      62.154.221.8
> ws-dhcp3.pziemann.de.     IN     MX     30     mail.pziemann.de.
> ws-dhcp3.pziemann.de.     IN     MX     40     zeus.nic.dtag.de.
> ws6.pziemann.de.     IN     CNAME     ws-dhcp3.pziemann.de.
> A8.pziemann.de.     IN     CNAME     ws-dhcp3.pziemann.de.
> ws-dhcp4.pziemann.de.     IN     A      62.154.221.9
> ws-dhcp4.pziemann.de.     IN     MX     30     mail.pziemann.de.
> ws-dhcp4.pziemann.de.     IN     MX     40     zeus.nic.dtag.de.
> ws7.pziemann.de.     IN     CNAME     ws-dhcp4.pziemann.de.
> A9.pziemann.de.     IN     CNAME     ws-dhcp4.pziemann.de.
> ws-dhcp5.pziemann.de.     IN     A      62.154.221.10
> ws-dhcp5.pziemann.de.     IN     MX     30     mail.pziemann.de.
> ws-dhcp5.pziemann.de.     IN     MX     40     zeus.nic.dtag.de.
> ws8.pziemann.de.     IN     CNAME     ws-dhcp5.pziemann.de.
> A10.pziemann.de.     IN     CNAME     ws-dhcp5.pziemann.de.
> ws-dhcp6.pziemann.de.     IN     A      62.154.221.11
> ws-dhcp6.pziemann.de.     IN     MX     30     mail.pziemann.de.
> ws-dhcp6.pziemann.de.     IN     MX     40     zeus.nic.dtag.de.
> ws9.pziemann.de.     IN     CNAME     ws-dhcp6.pziemann.de.
> A11.pziemann.de.     IN     CNAME     ws-dhcp6.pziemann.de.
> ppp-dialin1.pziemann.de.     IN     A      62.154.221.12
> ppp-dialin1.pziemann.de.     IN     MX     30     mail.pziemann.de.
> ppp-dialin1.pziemann.de.     IN     MX     40     zeus.nic.dtag.de.
> A12.pziemann.de.     IN     CNAME     ppp-dialin1.pziemann.de.
> ppp-dialin2.pziemann.de.     IN     A      62.154.221.13
> ppp-dialin2.pziemann.de.     IN     MX     30     mail.pziemann.de.
> ppp-dialin2.pziemann.de.     IN     MX     40     zeus.nic.dtag.de.
> A13.pziemann.de.     IN     CNAME     ppp-dialin2.pziemann.de.
> mgmt.pziemann.de.     IN     A      62.154.221.14
> mgmt.pziemann.de.     IN     MX     30     mail.pziemann.de.
> mgmt.pziemann.de.     IN     MX     40     zeus.nic.dtag.de.
> A14.pziemann.de.     IN     CNAME     mgmt.pziemann.de.
>
> John <elrassi at yahoo.com> wrote in message
> news:7L1p4.16423$W4.812881 at news1.rdc1.on.wave.home.com...
> > well it looks like it's working now
> >
> >
> >
> >