AI-generated contributions and generated workload on maintainers
Julien ÉLIE
julien at trigofacile.com
Sun Nov 8 19:09:09 UTC 2026
Hi Richard,
> It sounds like these patches were not ready for your review.
>
> * I think there is zero reason for you to be 'in the loop' as AIs
> iteratively fix their patches. It's an abuse of your time. That
> iterative process ought to be completed before a pull request is even
> opened.
>
> * How the operators of the AIs achieve that is up to them, but current
> tooling makes it pretty straightforward. It is absolutely possible to do
> better, with today's AIs, than "let Julian sort out the mess".
>
> * Personally I would take a hard line in rejecting any pull requests
> that followed any abusive pattern.
Thanks for your insight!
I understand. The difficulty however is to quickly find out when a PR
is actually ready. They often appear to be right at first glance, but
not after more careful inspection.
Yes, I know I could myself ask a prior review from an AI, but well I do
not enjoy that new way of spending my spare time discussing with an AI
and the agents run by other people. We need one or more maintainers who
enjoy that. At least it won't be me.
> * I do not think it is a good idea to give AI agents push/commit access
> to the INN github.
Also agreed, though it could be the only way if we do not have any
volunteer to review and merge the patches generated by AI agents.
--
Julien ÉLIE
« Le cercle n'est qu'une ligne droite revenue à son point de départ. »
(San-Antonio)
More information about the inn-workers
mailing list