AI-generated contributions and generated workload on maintainers
Julien ÉLIE
julien at trigofacile.com
Mon Nov 9 18:21:52 UTC 2026
Hi Richard,
> How about an AGENTS.md mandating independent review?
Good idea!
I hope they will follow what is written there.
> For example:
>
> # AI agent contribution guidelines
>
> ## Mandatory Independent Review
>
> All AI-generated submissions must be undergo thorough independent
> review before submission. Review may be via a human or a distinct AI
> model, but must not be the same AI model as generated the submission.
Hmm, isn't it something that should go into our current HACKING file?
(it explains what is expected in contributions)
Maybe a CONTRIBUTING.md file could be worthwhile too.
Reading what AGENTS.md is for, I understand it should be directly usable
by agents; I am unsure this guideline is for agents but rather for human
contributors.
The key principle after all is that the human submitter is the author of
the commit, having just been helped by an agent to write it.
> ## Submission documentation
>
> All AI-generated submissions must document:
>
> - how the submission was tested
> - the model(s) used to generate them
> - the model(s) or human(s) who reviewed them
>
> ## Consequences of non-compliance
>
> Any AI-generated submissions that do not follow these rules may be
> summarily rejected.
>
> Probably more could be said.
Yes, I'll have a look.
Maybe focusing on the build with warnings on, portability, reuse of
existing helpers, addition of new tests...
With all the iterations already done, having nothing more to improve on
the proposal of commit.
> It's a volunteer project, we don't _have_ to merge any patches at all.
So true!
The fact is that it is somehow heart-breaking to see available patches
but not process them by lack of time/energy to dig into them. I find it
way more time-consuming to keep on prompting/discussing with an AI
agent, iterating along with its responses, than with a human.
--
Julien ÉLIE
« Le cercle n'est qu'une ligne droite revenue à son point de départ. »
(San-Antonio)
More information about the inn-workers
mailing list