AI-generated contributions and generated workload on maintainers
Noel Butler
noel.butler at ausics.net
Mon Nov 9 23:51:24 UTC 2026
On 10/11/2026 08:44, Thomas Hochstein wrote:
> Julien ÉLIE wrote:
>
>> There are several AI agents from OpenAI and Anthropic running on INN
>> codebase, submitting bug fixes and security reviews.
>
> I don't think it is acceptable to let AI agents submit PRs or issues
> unsupervised ...
>
>> I do not want to spend my spare time and my evenings reading
>> and discussing with an AI on PRs and the issue tracker. It responds
>> within minutes with questions, decisions to make, proposals, etc.
>> It even said yesterday "I'm not a C expert myself. Your review
>> remains
>> the real check." Well, it knows C far better than I and does not take
>> any responsibility in its work...
>> It announced tons of upcoming patches, concluding with "@Julien-Elie
>> be
>> prepared ?"
>
> ... and force the maintainer to "chat" with the agent via comments.
>
> The right way - IMNSHO - is to check (!) and submit issues and PRs
> through a human.
>
>> I say "most" because I spotted weird things and inaccuracies in some
>> submitted patches. And a few minutes after highlighting these, the
>> responses came:
>> "You are right, the reproduction steps are wrong: newsgroups: and
>> post:
>> can't be combined."
>> "my patch added the field name to its new error message but indeed
>> missed this one"
>> "I mis-copied it"
>> "I withdraw the sentence. I haven't substantiated it."
>
> I find that unacceptable.
>
>> So, what to do next?
>>
>> A proposal to discuss: couldn't we give push/commit access to the
>> GitHub
>> users running AI agents? This way, they could automatically work and
>> improve the code as well as open and close PRs and tickets.
>
> Your examples show that - at least - not all submissions would improve
> the code.
>
> I wouldn't give agents commit access, but rather block them. AI agents
> can be a helpful tool, but I think the onus to check their output,
> submit it and communicate with the maintainer should be on the
> contributor.
>
> Regards,
> -thh
+1
It's scary to think of the number of people who know nothing about a
subject and just blindly accepting whatever their flavour of AI tells
them, seriously, did we not learn anything back in the day from the
dangers of search engines results.
--
_Regards,_
_Noel Butler_
-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
URL: <https://lists.isc.org/pipermail/inn-workers/attachments/20261110/e1e8ab7d/attachment.htm>
More information about the inn-workers
mailing list